Jump to content

Can I Patent My Mobile App?

From WikiPatents

Can I Patent My Mobile App?

Mobile app developers often wonder about intellectual property protection for their innovations. Understanding whether you can patent your mobile app, and the best approach to securing that protection, requires navigating specific aspects of patent law and application requirements.

Mobile App Patentability Fundamentals

Patent Eligibility for Mobile Applications

Mobile apps may qualify for patent protection when they meet the standard requirements for patentability:

  • Novelty - The app must contain new features not previously disclosed in prior art
  • Non-obviousness - The app's innovations must not be obvious to someone skilled in app development
  • Utility - The app must serve a useful purpose
  • Patent-eligible subject matter - The app must qualify under patentable subject matter requirements

The last requirement presents the most significant challenge for mobile app patents following the Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International Supreme Court decision, which raised the bar for software patent eligibility.[1]

What Can Be Patented in Mobile Apps

Not all aspects of mobile applications qualify for patent protection. Patentable elements typically include:

  • Novel technical processes within the app
  • Unique methods of organizing or processing data
  • Innovative user interfaces with technical implementation details
  • Specific hardware-software integration features
  • New communication protocols or system architectures

The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has granted thousands of patents related to mobile applications, particularly those that solve specific technical problems in a non-obvious way.[2]

Technical Considerations for Mobile App Patents

Software vs. Hardware Components

Mobile app patents often involve both software and hardware elements:

  • Software Components - Novel algorithms, data processing methods, or user experience flows
  • Hardware Integration - Interactions with device components like cameras, sensors, GPS, or network hardware
  • System Architecture - The structural organization of app components and their interactions

Applications combining software with hardware elements typically face fewer subject matter eligibility challenges than those focused solely on software implementations.

Overcoming Subject Matter Eligibility Challenges

To address the challenges posed by the Alice framework, successful mobile app patents typically:

  • Focus on specific technical improvements rather than abstract concepts
  • Detail how the app solves a technical problem in computing itself
  • Emphasize improvements to device functionality
  • Specify hardware components and their interaction with the software
  • Describe concrete implementation details rather than high-level concepts

Companies like Apple and Google frequently secure patents for mobile app innovations by emphasizing these technical aspects in their patent applications.[3]

Types of Mobile App Features That Gain Patent Protection

User Interface Innovations

Novel user interfaces may be patentable when they include:

  • Technical implementations that improve device functionality
  • New methods of user interaction (G06F3/0487 for touch interaction)
  • Specific technological improvements to interface performance

Samsung has secured numerous patents for mobile user interface elements that provide specific technical solutions to interface challenges.[4]

Functional Processes

Process-focused patents protect specific methods within mobile apps:

  • Data processing algorithms
  • Communication methods
  • Authentication processes
  • Media handling techniques

Qualcomm has obtained extensive patent protection for mobile communication and data processing methods that enhance network efficiency.[5]

System Architecture

Architectural elements may qualify for patents when they include:

  • Novel component arrangements
  • Innovative data flow structures
  • Efficient resource management systems
  • Unique client-server interactions

Amazon has secured patents for mobile app architectures that efficiently manage distributed computing resources.[6]

Hardware-Software Integration

Mobile app features that interact with device hardware in novel ways are often strong patent candidates:

  • Camera processing techniques
  • Sensor data analysis methods
  • Location-based service implementations
  • Battery optimization approaches

Uber has patented numerous mobile app features that process location data in innovative ways to improve transportation services.[7]

Alternative Protection Strategies for Mobile Apps

Copyright Protection

While patents protect functional aspects, copyright automatically protects:

  • The source code of the app
  • Visual elements and design
  • Original content within the app
  • The arrangement and selection of elements

Copyright provides immediate protection without filing requirements, though registration with the U.S. Copyright Office provides additional legal benefits.[8]

Trade Secret Protection

For algorithms or methods difficult to reverse-engineer:

  • Keep innovative aspects confidential
  • Implement access controls
  • Use encryption for sensitive code
  • Require confidentiality agreements

Snapchat initially protected its disappearing message feature as a trade secret before seeking patent protection.[9]

Trademark Protection

To protect the app's brand identity:

  • Register the app name as a trademark
  • Protect logos and distinctive visual elements
  • Secure domain names and social media handles
  • Monitor app stores for infringing apps

Duolingo has registered multiple trademarks to protect its brand identity in the education app market.[10]

Strategic Approach to Mobile App Patents

When to Consider Patent Protection

Patent protection is particularly valuable when your mobile app:

  • Contains truly innovative technical solutions
  • Has substantial commercial potential
  • Would benefit from licensing opportunities
  • Faces potential competitive copying
  • Represents a core business asset

Airbnb chose to patent key technical features of its mobile app that provide unique competitive advantages in the travel booking market.[11]

Conducting a Patentability Assessment

Before investing in patent applications:

  • Perform a thorough prior art search
  • Identify specific technical innovations
  • Evaluate commercial significance
  • Assess likely subject matter eligibility
  • Consider international filing requirements

Innography, a patent analytics company, recommends conducting comprehensive mobile technology landscape analyses before filing app patents.[12]

Cost Considerations

Patent protection involves several cost components:

  • Patent search (typically $1,000-$3,000)
  • Patent application drafting ($7,000-$15,000 for mobile app patents)
  • USPTO filing fees ($400-$1,600 depending on entity size)
  • Prosecution costs ($3,000-$10,000 over 2-4 years)
  • Maintenance fees ($400-$7,000 over the patent lifetime)

For startups with limited resources, Y Combinator advises focusing patent efforts on core technological innovations rather than attempting to patent every app feature.[13]

Industry-Specific Considerations

Fintech Mobile Apps

Financial technology apps (G06Q20) face particular challenges due to abstract idea rejections. Successful patents typically focus on:

  • Security improvements
  • Technical fraud prevention methods
  • Specific data processing techniques
  • Hardware-integrated authentication

PayPal has secured numerous patents for mobile payment technologies by emphasizing specific technical implementations rather than financial concepts.[14]

Healthcare Mobile Apps

Medical and healthcare apps (G16H) may find stronger patent protection by emphasizing:

  • Diagnostic data processing methods
  • Medical device integration
  • Patient monitoring techniques
  • Specific healthcare workflows

Medtronic has patented mobile app features that interface with medical devices in ways that improve patient outcomes.[15]

Gaming Applications

Mobile game patents (A63F13) often focus on:

  • Novel rendering techniques
  • Game mechanics with technical implementation
  • Multiplayer synchronization methods
  • Resource optimization approaches

Niantic has secured patents for augmented reality game features that solve specific technical problems in mobile gaming.[16]

Questions about Patenting Mobile Apps

What Specific Mobile App Features Are Most Likely to Qualify for Patent Protection?

Technical innovations that solve specific computing problems have the strongest patent potential. Features with the highest patentability include: novel algorithms that improve device performance or battery efficiency; unique technical implementations of security measures that go beyond conventional approaches; innovative methods for processing or displaying data that enhance user interaction; backend synchronization techniques that solve technical challenges; hardware-software integration features that leverage device capabilities in non-obvious ways; and location-based service implementations with technical improvements. A key consideration is whether your feature solves a technical problem rather than a business or user experience problem—for example, a new method for processing images on limited mobile resources would be more patentable than a new business model implemented through an app. Focus on features that competitors would struggle to replicate without accessing your specific technical approach, rather than those that could be implemented through alternative methods.

How Does My Mobile App Patent Strategy Differ Between iOS and Android Platforms?

Platform-specific considerations should inform your mobile app patent strategy. For iOS-focused patents, emphasize integration with Apple's ecosystem, particularly features leveraging Apple's hardware capabilities like FaceID, ARKit, or the Neural Engine. iOS patents often benefit from detailing interactions with Apple's development frameworks and APIs in ways that improve performance or user experience. For Android patents, address the challenges of device fragmentation with innovations that function across diverse hardware environments. Android patents may focus more on background processing, notification systems, or resource optimization for varying device capabilities. When targeting both platforms, consider a two-tiered approach: draft broader claims covering fundamental technology applicable to both platforms, then include platform-specific dependent claims addressing unique implementations. Remember that platform constraints often drive innovation—features developed to overcome platform limitations may represent more patentable subject matter than those simply implementing platform capabilities. Finally, consider how your patent strategy aligns with each platform's development cycle and update frequency.

How Do I Balance Patent Protection with the Rapid Development Cycle of Mobile Apps?

Balancing patent protection with rapid mobile app development requires a strategic approach. Start by implementing an efficient invention disclosure process that captures innovations without disrupting development workflows—many companies use simplified technical disclosure forms that developers can complete quickly. Consider filing provisional patent applications for significant innovations, which establishes a priority date while providing 12 months to evaluate commercial potential before committing to a full application. Develop clear criteria for what warrants patent protection versus what should be protected through other IP mechanisms or simply released quickly. Establish a tiered patent strategy: secure foundational patents for core technologies with longer relevance, while using faster protection mechanisms like design patents or copyright for features with shorter lifecycles. Create a dedicated patent review committee that meets regularly to evaluate recent developments. Consider batch filing related innovations to reduce administrative overhead and legal costs. Finally, integrate patent considerations into your development roadmap to identify potential innovations before release cycles, allowing patent applications to be prepared in parallel with development rather than as an afterthought.

What's the Difference Between Patenting the App Itself and Patenting Specific Features?

The distinction between patenting an entire mobile app versus specific features has important strategic implications. Patenting an entire app typically involves broad system claims covering the overall architecture, data flow, and functionality of the application as a comprehensive solution. This approach provides broader protection but faces greater eligibility challenges under the Alice framework, as courts are skeptical of claims that encompass an entire application without specific technical improvements. Feature-specific patents, by contrast, focus on discrete technical innovations within the app—a specific algorithm, data processing method, or user interface mechanism. These narrower patents generally face fewer eligibility challenges and are more defensible when limited to specific technical implementations. Most successful mobile app patent strategies employ a hybrid approach: filing feature-specific patents for key innovations with clear technical contributions, while using broader application architecture patents to protect the overall system when possible. This layered approach creates a patent portfolio where individual components may remain valid even if broader patents face challenges, while still providing comprehensive protection against competitors attempting to replicate your entire solution.

How Can I Enforce My Mobile App Patent Against Competitors?

Effective enforcement of mobile app patents requires a multi-faceted approach beginning with diligent monitoring. Implement regular app store searches and use specialized monitoring services to identify potentially infringing applications. When potential infringement is detected, conduct a thorough technical analysis—this often requires reverse engineering within legal boundaries to determine if the competitor's implementation actually practices your patented claims. Before initiating litigation, consider direct communication through a cease and desist letter or licensing offer, as many disputes resolve at this stage. If litigation becomes necessary, be prepared for substantial costs—mobile app patent litigation typically ranges from $300,000 to several million dollars through trial. Alternative enforcement strategies include: offering licenses to competitors; pursuing complaints through app store platforms, which may remove infringing apps; targeting the most egregious or threatening infringers rather than attempting to pursue all possible infringements; and considering international enforcement in key markets where your patent protection extends. Remember that the strength of your enforcement position depends heavily on how specifically your patent claims were drafted—overly broad claims may be invalidated during litigation, while precisely drafted technical claims stand a better chance of being upheld and enforced.

References

  1. ↑ Supreme Court of the United States, "Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International," 573 U.S. 208 (2014)
  2. ↑ USPTO, "Examination Guidelines for Computer-Implemented Inventions," https://www.uspto.gov/patents/laws/examination-policy/subject-matter-eligibility
  3. ↑ Apple Inc., "Patents," https://www.apple.com/legal/intellectual-property/
  4. ↑ Samsung, "Innovation," https://www.samsung.com/us/about-us/innovation/
  5. ↑ Qualcomm, "Patents and Licensing," https://www.qualcomm.com/
  6. ↑ Amazon, "AWS Innovations," https://aws.amazon.com/
  7. ↑ Uber, "Technology," https://www.uber.com/
  8. ↑ U.S. Copyright Office, "Copyright Basics," https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ01.pdf
  9. ↑ Snap Inc., "Intellectual Property," https://snap.com/
  10. ↑ Duolingo, "Brand Guidelines," https://www.duolingo.com/
  11. ↑ Airbnb, "Innovation," https://news.airbnb.com/
  12. ↑ Innography, "Patent Landscapes," https://www.innography.com/
  13. ↑ Y Combinator, "Startup IP Guide," https://www.ycombinator.com/
  14. ↑ PayPal, "Technology," https://www.paypal.com/
  15. ↑ Medtronic, "Digital Health Solutions," https://www.medtronic.com/
  16. ↑ Niantic, "Technology," https://nianticlabs.com/
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.